S&P Oyster Company | Mystic CT
 
Join our emailing system to receive notice of
special offers and more...

Subscribe Unsubscribe

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

S&P Oyster Company Menu Spring / Summer Selections



Fresh Beginnings


Printable .PDF Menu

Premium Oysters (minimum of three)  each $2.35
Baked Oysters (3) topped with bacon Cognac butter $7.95
Fried Oysters with a creamy horseradish sauce $12.95
Oysters Our Way (3) baked with Swiss cheese & garlic butter $7.95
Fried Calamari with fried onions, sweet red peppers & pepperoncinis served with a tangy aioli dipping sauce $9.50
Spicy Mediterranean Calamari fried, then sautéed with Kalamata olives, sun dried tomatoes, artichokes and spicy pepper rings $10.25
Seafood Stuffed Potato Skins lobster, shrimp & crab in a special sauce, topped with Swiss cheese & scallions $10.35
Wood Grilled Certified Angus Beef Tenderloin tips served on Ciabatta toast with roasted red pepper Gorgonzola sauce stacked on a wood grilled Spanish Onion $11.95
Warm Spinach & Artichoke Dip with our own flat bread chips $8.25
Prince Edward Island Mussels sautéed with leeks, white burgundy & garlic  $9.95
Yellowfin Tuna brushed with Caribbean spices then wood grilled served on Lavosh crisps with a Wasabi aioli $11.95
Wood Grilled Proscuitto Wrapped Sea Scallops served over sautéed shallots, baby spinach, capers and lemon juice $11.99
Seafood Crepe shrimp, crab and lobster with a madiera cream sauce $10.25
Mini Crab Cakes with a spicy aioli sauce $9.95
Lobster Salad with Fresh Tarragon over avocado salsa with a balsamic reduction $12.95
Jumbo Shrimp wood grilled with a spicy remoulade or steamed with cocktail sauce (minimum of three) each $2.95


Soups
       
Lobster Bisque cup $6.25  bowl $8.95
New England Clam Chowder cup $4.50  bowl $5.95
Seafood White Bean Chili served with our own corn tortilla chips      crock $6.95
Oyster Stew       bowl $8.95


On The Lighter Side
 
Lobster Quiche with asparagus, sun dried tomatoes and Pecorino Romano cheese served with mixed greens $14.75
Petite Filet Mignon 5 oz. crowned with a port wine reduction served over a Yucca croquette and vegetables $16.99
Mixed Grill Sampler jumbo shrimp, Stonington Sea scallops & Yellowfin tuna served over polenta with a garlic lime sauce $17.95
Lobster Tacos two wood grilled corn tortillas filled with fresh lobster sautéed with Pico de Gallo and served over Salsa Verde $11.95
Penne Athena  chopped Roma tomatoes and asparagus tossed with a baby spinach cream sauce topped with toasted sunflower seeds $12.95
Chicken Tuscany wood grilled chicken tossed with pesto sauce, broccoli, artichokes and Penne finished with chopped tomatoes and Feta cheese $13.50
Black Tiger Shrimp, Lemon & Parmesan with asparagus and Whole Wheat Linguini $13.95


Salads
 
Rocket Salad a colorful mixture with red beets and carrots topped with tomatoes, red onion and Romano shavings $6.95
S & P’s House Salad mixed greens with mandarin oranges, almond slices, raisins, tomatoes, red onion & Gorgonzola cheese, tossed with a House vinaigrette  $7.75
Baby Spinach & Wood Grilled Fuji Apples with sunflower seeds, dried cranberries & goat cheese finished with our Cranberry Balsamic vinaigrette $6.95
Caesar Salad with Fresh Anchovies & Parmesan crisps $7.95
Wood Grilled Vegetable Salad asparagus, eggplant, portabella mushroom,  red pepper and Spanish onions served over mixed greens with a roasted shallot vinaigrette sprinkled with Feta cheese
$9.95

Top one of our salads with wood grilled:
Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $8.00, Yellowfin Tuna $9.00
Pan seared Stonington Sea Scallops $8.00



Lunch Selections served until 4:00 PM

 
 
S & P’s Seafood Pasta shrimp, Stonington sea scallops, calamari & mussels tossed with fresh basil and Tagliatelle pasta in a white wine garlic sauce $14.99
Baked Stuffed Sole topped with a creamy lobster sauce $12.99
Broiled Seafood Platter shrimp, Stonington sea scallops, and stuffed sole drizzled with lobster sauce $16.95
Caribbean Chicken & Shrimp Salad wood grilled with Island spices and topped with a fresh pineapple salsa $13.99
Wood Grilled Tenderloin Salad with sweet peppers & Gorgonzola cheese $14.95
Seafood Ambrosia shrimp, Stonington sea  scallops, crab & Native cod topped with our seafood stuffing $14.95
Mini Bouillabaisse served with vegetables and rosemary red potatoes  $16.95


Sandwiches served until 4:00 PM

All sandwiches are served with Mystic Chips & a tangy cucumber, cabbage & onion salad.
If you prefer potato salad or french fries instead of chips, add $1.50
 

 
Lobster Salad Roll served the New England way; on a hotdog roll and lightly tossed with mayonnaise, celery, & black pepper $16.99
Warm Lobster Roll 5 oz. of lobster sautéed with butter $17.50
Oyster Grinder sautéed with garlic, basil, fresh peppers & onions, topped with Gorgonzola cheese $12.99
California Vegetable Burger topped with Swiss cheese, tomato, avocado & sprouts $7.99
Portabella Mushroom Sandwich wood grilled & topped with spinach, roasted red peppers & Swiss cheese in gyro bread  $8.50
Bacon Cheddar Burger Certified Angus Beef with Vermont white cheddar $8.99
Chicken Cobb Sandwich wood grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, plum tomatoes, chopped romaine lettuce, red onion and a creamy avocado bleu cheese sauce  $8.75
Pulled Pork Tenderloin Sandwich in a spicy BBQ style sauce topped with fried onion straws  $8.99


Fish & Shellfish served all day

All Entrées, excluding pastas, are served with vegetables and your choice of rosemary red potatoes, Basmati rice or mashed potatoes, unless otherwise noted.
 

New England Whole Lobster Dinner a pound and a quarter $27.99
Alaskan King Crab Legs approximately a pound and a quarter $29.99
Crab Cakes sautéed, topped with a creamy caper sauce served over a Yucca croquette and julienne vegetables $21.99
Seafood Ambrosia shrimp, Stonington sea scallops, crab & cod topped with our seafood stuffing $21.95
Bouillabaisse Chef White’s rendition of a French Classic $23.95
Yellowfin Tuna wood grilled & brushed with a soy ginger Wasabi sauce served with rice and julienne vegetables $23.50
North Atlantic Salmon farmed raised, wood grilled topped with a lemon dill caper sauce served with grilled asparagus and Yucca croquette $19.99
Sicilian Swordfish wood grilled then baked with capers, scallions, basil, garlic,
shitake mushrooms and plum tomatoes
$21.99
Baked Stuffed Sole topped with a creamy lobster sauce $18.95
Blackened Seasoned Tilapia topped with pineapple salsa, placed on a bed of sautéed fresh spinach & served with rice $17.50
Broiled Seafood Platter shrimp, Stonington sea scallops and stuffed sole drizzled with lobster sauce $22.50
Wood Grilled Jumbo Shrimp with a BBQ soy sauce and served with Basmati rice and seaweed salad $18.99
 

Baked stuffed add

$4.00


Fried items are hand breaded and served with french fries & a tangy cucumber, cabbage & onion salad, unless otherwise noted
 

 
Fresh Native Cod traditional fish & chips or broiled with rice and vegetables $13.50
Fisherman’s Platter shrimp, cod & Stonington sea scallops, served with french fries and a tangy cucumber, cabbage and onion salad $21.95
Fried Oyster Dinner served with french fries and a tangy cucumber, cabbage and onion salad $18.99


Pastas served all day

 
 
S & P’s Seafood Pasta shrimp, Stonington sea scallops, calamari & mussels tossed with fresh basil & Tagliatelle pasta in a white wine garlic sauce $22.75
Cajun Shrimp Alfredo tossed with linguini, garnished with scallions $19.99
Roasted Wild Mushroom Ravioli with spinach, scallions, sweet peppers, sun dried tomatoes & artichokes in a light cream sauce finished with Goat cheese  $17.95
Penne Rigate Jumbo Black Tiger shrimp, calamari and a classic Italian sausage
from Bruno’s market with vegetable al forno in a spicy marinara sauce
$21.95
Pan Seared Stonington Sea Scallops with pancetta, oven roasted tomatoes & shallots in a lemon cream sauce tossed with Tagliatelle pasta $22.95
Lobster Alfredo one half pound of lobster tossed with Linguini and topped with roasted red peppers $28.95


Beef, Chicken & Pork served all day


We are proud to serve only Certified Angus Beef
 
14 oz. NY Strip topped with a Poblano pepper and Patron Tequila sauce with a hint of Cointreau, served with mashed potatoes and vegetables $29.95
8 oz. Rib Eye Steak with a chili rub topped with spicy onion rings & Pico de Gallo $18.95
Tenderloin Tips & Portabella Mushroom both wood grilled, topped with Gorgonzola cheese and scallions, served with mashed potatoes and vegetables $17.95
Pork Tenderloin Medallions wood grilled with a spicy rustic rub served with vegetables and mashed potatoes $17.95
Wood Grilled Garlic Lemon Chicken sautéed with sun dried tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms & artichokes over rice  $16.99
S & P's Chicken Marsala our sauce made with sun dried tomatoes, baby spinach, Portabella mushrooms served over mashed potatoes $17.50


Children’s Menu for children 8 and under
 
Fish & Chips hand breaded cod bites $7.99
Fried Shrimp Dinner served with French fries $9.95
Penne with Pecorino Romano cheese tossed with a little butter $6.99
Grilled Chicken Dinner wood grilled breast of chicken with mashed potatoes and vegetables $7.99
Chicken Tenders Dinner with a BBQ dipping sauce, served with french fries $7.50
Cheeseburger Certified Angus Beef served with Vermont Cheddar and Mystic chips $8.25


Dessert Selections
S & P’s Famous Bread Pudding served warm with an Amaretto sauce and whip cream, sprinkled with cinnamon  
NY Style Cheesecake traditional recipe with an Oreo cookie crust, garnished with a Raspberry sauce and whip cream  
Flourless Chocolate Cake a rich dense chocolate cake ribboned with caramel and chocolate sauces with whip cream  
Crème Brulee classic custard dessert topped with a caramelized sugar crust garnished with a Raspberry sauce and fresh mint  
Tiramisu a light composition of layered coffee infused lady fingers, Mascarpone cheese and grated chocolate.  


Coffee Drinks
Irish Jameson’s, coffee, whip cream and a dash of Crème de Menthe  
Keoke Kahlua, Brandy, coffee and whip cream  
Fragile Baby Frangelico, Bailey’s, coffee and whip cream  
Bavarian Kahlua, Frangelico and Peppermint Schnapps with coffee  
Chocolate Chambord Chambord, Crème de Cacao, coffee and whip cream  
Jamaican Tia Maria, Myers and coffee with whip cream  
Café Amaretto Amaretto Di Saronno, coffee and whip cream  
B-52 Bailey’s, Kahlua, Grand Marnier and coffee  
Café Mocha Hot chocolate, coffee and whip cream  


Take a bit of S & P home with you!
A Pint of Soup or Chili:
New England Clam Chowder $8.95
Lobster Bisque $10.95
Seafood Chili $10.95
   
Sea Salt $5.00
Seven Grain Bread $5.00
   
S & P Pint Glass $5.00
S & P Crayon Glass $3.00
S & P T-shirt $20.00
S & P Polo Shirt $28.00
S & P Hat $18.00


S & P Information
 
  • Gift certificates are available on our website.
  • An $8.00 plate charge applies to any split entrees.
  • “Thoroughly cooking meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs reduces the risk of food-borne illnesses.”
  • An 18% gratuity is added to parties of 8 or more.
  • The best view in Mystic is available for your special occasion or business function.
  • Our menu items and prices are subject to change.
  • No cell phones, please respect our other guests.