Location & Hours

1 Holmes Street, Mystic, Connecticut 06355

Sunday – Thursday: 11:30AM – 9:00PM
Friday – Saturday: 11:30AM – 10:00PM

Priority Seating

Reduce your time waiting and call for priority seating! Similar to a reservation, S&P adds your name to our priority list for the time you request. Guests on the list are seated as close to that time, before any walk-in diners. Although we do not hold tables, you will have priority over those who did not call in advance. Spaces are limited; our priority seating list is very popular and tends to fill several days in advance.

Be sure to call ahead at: 860-536-2674

  • My wife and I can't go to Mystic without a stop here for great food. We visit with friends celebrated anniversaries. It's simply the best.

    HarrisSavin tripadvisor
  • We were in Mystic for an overnight stay, and decided to have dinner at the S & P Oyster Co. I am so glad that we did!

    Nashvillenative2013 tripadvisor
  • I can't get enough of the bread and dipping oil, or the main course, no matter what it is. The service is perfect.

    Tamara M. tripadvisor
  • The service here is top notch. The servers know their stuff... Staff is on point, atmosphere is beautiful, view is out of this world. HIGHLY recommend.

    Cheryl A. TripAdvisor
  • The food, the drinks, the table with the great view, the ambiance, the terrific servers Allison and Courtney, the personable hostess... it was all wonderful... will definitely return again and again!

    Joe V. TripAdvisor
  • The top floor bar has a tremendous view. More importantly, the staff were very friendly and the bartenders were creating a new Bloody Mary and asked for our input... Highly recommend

    George K. TripAdvisor
  • I was mentioning to my wife that I thought it may be the best fish I ever had (and I am a fish eater). Overheard the next table also mention it was the best fish they ever had... I will definitely sto

    Tonyinmanchester TripAdvisor
  • Our servers were friendly and very helpful. They were able to meet any request and were happy to talk to the chef in the kitchen for us.

    mystikmom TripAdvisor
  • Ask to be seated upstairs, where the water view from the windows is really nice. The staff is courteous, personable without being overly-familiar, and gave us exceptional service.

    ilovekauai5 TripAdvisor
  • The food was great and our servers, Jeremy, Allison & Kristen were efficient and helpful with any questions regarding the menu. Can't wait to go back again! Also, the view is great!

    Linda N. TripAdvisor
  • Perfect setting by the river, with great holiday decorations. Nice service with a smile and a joke. Wide ranging menu and kids section. Lovely food with a South American twist.

    Diamond_Snowflake TripAdvisor
  • The stuffing on the Seafood Ambrosia is decadent, and the tuna on my Grilled Sampler was excellent. The consistency of the food and service at S&P is what brings me back every time.

    Kati M TripAdvisor
  • We were here for our anniversary and hoping for a nice meal. We got one of the best dinners ever, a gorgeous view and the best service! What really put this over the top were our two servers Jeremy an

    Renee Z TripAdvisor
  • I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a water view and some refreshingly tasty good food!!

    Stephanie S. TripAdvisor
  • Great location, view, food and staff! What more can you ask for? Pepper jack grits to die for! Couldn't keep husband's spoon out of my bowl.

    Lori D. TripAdvisor
  • Chocolate pots de creme and bread pudding were delicious ends to the meals. Service was also spot on. I'd love to come back in the spring time and enjoy dinner while watching the sunset over the water

    Genny77 TripAdvisor
  • My boyfriend and I went here for dinner while we were on a trip to Mystic, and it was so delicious...Our waiter and waitress were friendly and attentive and the whole evening was fantastic.

    Amy N. TripAdvisor
  • This is the second time I came here, one in the summer two years ago, now in the winter, and the excellent service and good food remain the same, if not better.

    Bezicorrea TripAdvisor
  • I have dined here on numerous occasions and have NEVER been disappointed. One of my favorite places in Connecticut.

    Maureen A. TripAdvisor
  • We've enjoyed this place for nine years on our way to and from Maine. Incredible food, friendly and very accomodating staff, plus beautiful views and lovely atmosphere! Service has always been wonderf

    PhilipR657 TripAdvisor

Be Social With Us!


facebook     instagram     twitter     twitter

Online Survey

Click here to complete our online survey and be entered to win a $100 gift certificate to S&P Oyster Company!

View past winners by clicking here!

Featured Food

Seafood Mac&Cheese
Seafood Mac & C...$28.95

$28.95 - Lobster, salmon, shrimp, calamari, and swordfish finished with a poblano cheese sauce.

Rate Us!